A selection of recent matters — judgments, settlements, dismissals, and reversals. Past results don't guarantee future outcomes, but they show how we work.
Patrick Wier represented a Florida home seller in a contested American Arbitration Association proceeding brought by a defaulting buyer under a residential real estate purchase agreement. The buyer had failed to make the required earnest money deposit and failed to close by the contractual deadline, then filed for arbitration seeking specific performance and damages — and recorded a lis pendens against the property in the meantime. Following final hearing under the AAA Expedited Commercial Arbitration Rules, the arbitrator denied all of the buyer's claims in their entirety, ordered the buyer to release and discharge the lis pendens within ten days, and ruled the seller entitled to recover her attorney's fees incurred in connection with the discharge. The decision freed the seller's home from a clouded title and restored her ability to convey the property.
Patrick Wier and Kelsey Black represented an executive whose former employer had withheld eight figures in equity and severance owed at separation. A strongly worded pre-suit demand produced full payment of the severance. After the firm filed suit on the unpaid equity, the client was fully compensated for that as well. From the date of Black Law's engagement to the conclusion of the matter, less than three months passed.
Kelsey Black defended a business in a foreclosure lawsuit brought by its condominium association. The dispute arose after years of unresolved leaks and deferred maintenance by the association prompted the client to withhold dues. The firm secured a resolution on terms substantially favorable to the client, ending the foreclosure without the loss of the property.
Kelsey Black represented a nurse in a sexual harassment claim against her former employer. Following an EEOC investigation, the client received a six-figure settlement offer, and the matter resolved quickly thereafter — securing meaningful compensation for the workplace conduct she endured, without the burden of prolonged litigation.
Cody Shilling, together with Kelsey Black, represented a physician expert witness owed more than $200,000 in unpaid fees by a Fortune 500 defendant that had retained him in an underlying personal injury matter. When ownership of the company changed mid-engagement, the new corporate parent pointed to the transition as a basis to refuse payment for work the doctor had already performed. The firm issued a formal demand letter accompanied by a draft complaint prepared for filing the day after the demand period expired. Before the deadline ran, the company reversed course and paid every dollar requested — recovering the full value of the doctor's work without litigation, and sparing the client further expense and delay.
Cody Shilling defended a lending company against allegations of fraud and conspiracy in hotly contested federal court litigation, securing dismissal of the complaint on standing grounds. The firm demonstrated that the plaintiff's claims amounted to little more than a fishing expedition. The dismissal ended the case before discovery began — sparing the client the cost, distraction, and reputational exposure of defending unsubstantiated fraud allegations in federal court.
Cody Shilling represented a set of grandparents whose son's contested divorce had entangled real estate they co-owned with the son and his former daughter-in-law. Mr. Shilling navigated the overlapping family and property issues to secure the return of the grandparents' properties — resolving a sensitive matter without protracted litigation, on terms acceptable to all sides.
Kelsey Black, together with co-counsel Cody Shilling, represented a Florida property owners association in a coverage dispute with its insurance carrier after the carrier refused to defend and indemnify the association in an underlying matter. Shortly after filing a declaratory judgment action, the firm secured a favorable resolution in which the carrier not only contributed funds toward the underlying settlement on the association's behalf, but also reimbursed the association in full for the attorneys' fees it had incurred to date. The early resolution spared the client the cost and uncertainty of prolonged coverage litigation while restoring the financial protections the association had bargained for under its policy.
Kelsey Black was hired to navigate a cruise ship vendor's defense in a catastrophic injury case after the trial court had already entered summary judgment for the plaintiff on liability — exposing the client to what could have been eight-figure damages despite earlier assurances that liability would not be an issue. The firm restructured the defense and negotiated a settlement within available insurance limits, closing the matter with no out-of-pocket cost to the client.
Kelsey Black represented a medical practitioner sued for high six figures over disputed invoices for medical products. Through extended mediation and disciplined advocacy, the firm secured a resolution requiring no payment from the client — closing the matter without any financial concession from the practitioner.
Kelsey Black represented a client in a federal court maritime case. Beyond resolving the underlying litigation, the firm navigated a settlement framework that placed the vessel into a profitable rental — turning an asset that had been a source of prolonged dispute into ongoing income for the client.
Kelsey Black represented a homeowner in a dispute with his former contractor — a prominent name in the Fort Lauderdale construction market — over issues arising during the build of a luxury home. Shortly after the firm's demand letter went out, the contractor agreed to resolve the matter on terms entirely favorable to the homeowner. The early resolution spared the client the cost and disruption of protracted litigation, securing the relief sought through disciplined pre-suit positioning alone.
Patrick Wier represented a dental practice sued for more than six figures on alleged outstanding debt for medical equipment. Working closely with the client to identify its goals, the firm negotiated a settlement for a fraction of the amount claimed — resolving the matter in under six weeks and sparing the practice the cost and distraction of prolonged litigation.
Kelsey Black represented a Florida homeowners association after its insurance carrier wrongfully denied coverage in an underlying lawsuit, forcing the association to fund its own defense and absorb mounting legal fees. Following Ms. Black's intervention, the firm successfully compelled the carrier to honor its coverage obligations, assume the defense of the underlying matter, and reimburse the association more than six figures in attorneys' fees the association had already paid out of pocket. The result transformed a client that had been hemorrhaging money in protracted litigation into one operating back in the black — vindicating the association's rights under its policy and restoring its financial footing.
Patrick Wier successfully obtained a favorable settlement for a South Florida medical practice against a major health insurance company in response to its wrongful recoupment of almost half a million in payments made.
Kelsey Black represented a physician-partner in a surgery center exit, securing over six figures in compensation within two months of negotiations.
Patrick Wier represented a Tampa-area doctor sued by a former employer seeking injunctive relief under a non-compete agreement. Carefully drafted opposition to the motion for injunctive relief prompted the plaintiff to withdraw the lawsuit the day before the injunction hearing — ending the matter on terms favorable to the doctor and entitling the client to recover its attorney's fees.
Kelsey Black and Cody Shilling navigated an appellate win for an air conditioner repair company: the Fourth District Court of Appeals upheld a favorable judgment and $60,000+ in attorney's fees after four years of litigation.
Cody Shilling represented a pilates studio in a federal age discrimination lawsuit. After months of litigation, the firm secured a dismissal with prejudice in U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida — ending the case before trial and closing the matter on terms entirely favorable to the client.
Individual defrauded by luxury car dealerships: judgment obtained against dealerships and principals after 3+ years litigation.
Maintenance company: complete recovery including all damages and attorney's fees in commercial drone purchase dispute.
Cody Shilling represented a corporate landlord in a contentious real estate dispute that had played out across multiple courts. The firm secured a highly favorable resolution for the client, closing the matter without further escalation.
Cody Shilling represented clients facing enforcement of a foreclosure judgment based on a forged promissory note. Through evidentiary hearings, the firm established improper service of process and succeeded in undoing the four-year-old judgment — relieving the clients of an obligation they had never legitimately incurred.
Couple who discovered closing lawyer forged court documents: secured clean title and judgment with attorney fees against disbarred lawyer.
Accounting firm partner: settlement encompassing all losses and complete company ownership within three months.
Kelsey Black, Patrick Wier, and Cody Shilling worked together to resolve a serious FLSA wage claim against the firm's client within weeks of engagement. The team's swift coordination significantly reduced the client's fee exposure and closed the matter before extended litigation could develop.
Cody Shilling represented a doctor in a pet replevin matter. Through skilled argumentation and effective cross-examination at the evidentiary hearing, the firm secured a successful outcome for the client.
Cody Shilling represented grandparents seeking to evict their daughter-in-law from a family property. After contentious hearings, the court ordered the eviction — restoring the clients' control of their own home.
Kelsey Black represented an Amazon seller whose account had been suspended. Within three days of the firm's involvement, the seller's account was reinstated — restoring the client's revenue stream with minimal disruption to the business.
Kelsey Black represented a pediatric surgery center in a dispute over a $70,000 emergency care bill. The firm secured full payment of the bill and reclassification of the patient as in-network — closing the matter on terms favorable to the medical practice.
Kelsey Black represented a medical provider with more than $300,000 in uncollected claims after the responsible health insurance company collapsed into insolvency. The firm negotiated a settlement valued at five times the insurer's original offer — recovering meaningful value for the client out of an otherwise distressed estate.
Kelsey Black defended a medical billing company against a claim exceeding $4 million in U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida. Days before trial, the firm resolved the case for a nominal value — sparing the client a multi-million-dollar exposure and the cost of jury trial.
Boat manufacturing claim: $287,000+ judgment plus attorney's fees; replevin order for marine equipment.
Kelsey Black defended a client against a breach of non-compete lawsuit that carried potential exposure in the seven figures. The firm secured dismissal of the claim — closing the matter without trial and resolving what could have been a years-long fight.
$975,000 vessel total loss: insurance paid entire loss minus deductible.
Kelsey Black represented a client defrauded of $55,000 in an aviation matter. The firm filed suit quickly and negotiated a favorable settlement — recovering the client's losses without protracted litigation.
Kelsey Black represented a client in a non-compete injunction matter. The firm secured court-ordered forensic examination of the ex-employee's computer, and the resulting evidence forced quick resolution of the case in the client's favor.
Kelsey Black represented a client whose warehouse security failure resulted in more than $1.6 million in theft losses. Over three years of litigation, the firm prosecuted the case through successful dispositive motions, ultimately securing full compensation for the client's losses.
HVAC product negligence claim dismissed four years into litigation, less than two weeks before trial; attorney fees expected.
Kelsey Black represented a pharmacy in a health center lawsuit. After two days of trial, the firm secured a seven-figure settlement for the client — vindicating the client's position before a verdict was reached.
Kelsey Black represented a client in federal court litigation. The firm obtained a temporary injunction against the opposing business, which forced settlement for the full value of the client's claim — vindicating the client's position before extensive litigation became necessary.
LLC owner dismissed with prejudice in product liability case.
Subcontractor unpaid invoices: defendants settled eve of trial for all requested damages.
Home fraud and misrepresentation: all damages plus attorney's fees awarded.
Law firm malpractice action: coverage obtained after two previous insurer denials.
Cruise ship worker injury claim: coverage secured, saving client tens of thousands.
Aviation parts company: judgment for all damages plus attorney's fees; post-judgment garnishment collected.
Improperly entered lis pendens and injunction dissolved; client enabled to litigate and bring real estate fraud counter-claim.
LLC members: successfully defended against piercing corporate veil collection efforts.
Construction client: third-party complaint against employee leasing company; settlement required leasing company to pay half.
Wholesale perfume vendor: entire damages amount plus attorney's fees awarded in breach of contract and unfair/deceptive trade practice case.
Restaurant client FLSA/retaliation claim: declaratory judgment action forced insurance carrier to resolve lawsuit.
Insurance filed federal court declaratory judgment; motion to dismiss led to voluntary dismissal.
Adverse inference instruction granted due to opposing party's evidence spoliation; case resolved for full damages.
CEO: immediate insurance carrier response secured fair settlement without lawsuit necessity.
Employee breach of non-compete: early mediation led to stronger non-compete agreement plus monetary damages.
Breach of contract / fraud / unfair practices: defense verdict on all but breach of contract claim.
Caribbean dive company in U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida: forced insurance to provide coverage despite exclusion attempt.
Commercial property: insurance persuaded pre-suit to cover 100% losses despite initial denial.
Five-day surety company trial: minimal damages against bond principal; defense verdict for surety.
One-week trial in closely held company: complete win for clients.
Closely held company dispute: favorable result for majority shareholders against minority shareholder.
Cannabis company speculative investment: full recovery value obtained.
Tell us what you're facing. We'll tell you how we'd approach it.